Monday's Quotelet: Deifying The Mundane.
"A lot of people said that it couldn't be done. But not only did we blatantly rip off 'WonderWall' note for note without raising an eyebrow - we even won a friggin' VMA for our efforts. Thanks, MTV!"
posted by Dave Pye @ 8/29/2005 02:12:00 PM
16 Comments:
"Thank you! This is going straight up my ass and I ain't sharing it with the other guys. Goodnight, everybody!"
I don't want to be an American idiot, but yet I am. Thank you!
That isn't a very good link you posted, it's a bullshit random comment with nothing to back it up.
The chords between the two songs are completely different. It's not even the same root chords by name, even if you take the Capo off Wonderwall. The most you could say is that the chords are relative to each other on the fretboard, but Noel plays open chords with a capo, and Billy-Joe plays power chords. - and it's all in a different rhyme. It's like comparing High and Dry to Come as you Are.
Evidence article A: Guitar Tab for BOBD
http://www.samsmith.co.nz/tab/GreenDay-AmericanIdiot.html#okenDreams
Evidence article B: Guitar Tab for Wonderwall
http://www.samsmith.co.nz/tab/Oasis-(WhatstheStory)MorningGlory.html#Wonderwall
Not to mention the songs sound completely different.
But seriously, this really is a great album, it's one of the best albums in the last couple years. Better than the Killers, better than Franz, and better than U2's latest.
I guess it's safe to say I struck a nerve there, Sam. Green Day fan, 12 o'clock high.
A well constructed argument. It still does not change the fact that Billy Joe's initials match those of naughty oral sex, that he wears more eyeliner than Robert Smith and makes Oompa Loompas look like Robert Parish.
more eyeliner that Robert Smith? That's pretty hard...
He does look like an Oompa Loompa and his initals are BJ, I can't argue about that...
I've been a casual greenday fan since Dookie, but the new album really surprised me when I picked it up a couple of months ago...
And I saw a stat before the VMA's, American Idiot has already sold 7 million albums... Dookie only sold 10... thats a shite load of cash...
I liked them up until they started drinking Baghdad Sean's Kool Aid.
I have a hard time taking the political leanings of a guy whose first hit was about punching the clown seriously.
I have no problem whatsoever, however, masturbating to the thought of the little dolled-up bastard being executed for treason.
What is Moynihan doing at the VMA's... more surprising - what is Moynihan doing sober?
I am a Green Day fan - but of the older songs. “Dookie” and “Insomniac” are wall-to-wall great albums ("Warning" is an awesome song but shite album). Ever since hearing "Good Riddance (Time of Your Life)" I have lost interest. What kind of a "punk" band comes up with schlock like that? Also, I saw them in concert last year for the American Idiot tour and it sucked - why the hell are they playing Queen covers? They have moved from an alternative band to totally wanting to be an anthem rock stadium band - for shame! Again, although I don’t mind the “American Idiot” song itself, the album as a whole is pretty crappy and if I hear that “Boulevard of Broken Dreams” song one more time I, I, I...don’t know what I’ll do. As far as in the pantheon of rock, Green Day is nowhere near U2, completely different than The Killers (and only time will only tell how long they last) and some might argue almost as influential as The Clash on reviving “punk” into the mainstream (although I think The Clash is a far more influential band). Now had they done a Clash cover live I might be singing a different tune!
Everyone has different tastes, but the only political song on this album is American Idiot. I don't know why people think the whole album is political. The rest of the album is a rock-opera about Jimmy. (Who at the end "shoots his brains out into the bay").
It's not like those other average GD albums since Dookie, and it's def. not punk. But it's still damn good. In my opinion.
“Boulevard of Broken Dreams” is one of the worst rock songs of 2005.
There's nothing "punk" about it, nothing rock about it, and in general it's just crap. I'm very disappointed it didn't win the "best group crap" award. That would have been cool.
Aw, Billy Joe is cute. I like his little suits.
They match his little pecker!
Pye, one correction to your previous comment - BJ actually wears as much eyeliner as Liza Minelli.
"We'd like to thank the millions of our 12 year old fans who bought the last album.
See you next year at the Nickelodeon Awards. WooHoo!
Brilliant Art. When you coming back to Boston?
Post a Comment
<< Home